VISUAL ESSAY / PUBLIC TRANSIT

The Downs-Thomson Paradox

FILM INDEX / JUMP TO AN ACT
FIELD GUIDE

A Wider Road, Slower City

Widening a road may shorten car trips at first. But if some bus passengers respond by driving, bus ridership falls. A transit agency trying to balance its budget may then run fewer buses, making transit less attractive and sending still more travelers to cars.

Road capacity first increases, and a visible group switches modes. The resulting loss of bus riders prompts a highlighted reduction in service frequency, followed by another round of switching. Rather than animate every small adjustment, the film moves to the new equilibrium and compares it with the original one. The paradox is that a road improvement can produce a worse combined road-and-transit outcome once the service response is included. Its lesson is about an interconnected transport market: evaluating a highway project from its immediate car-time saving alone can miss the effects it creates through transit frequency and mode choice.